6401 N Palafox St • Pensacola, FL 32503
5505 Industrial Blvd • Milton, FL 32584

Store Hours: M-F 8am-5pm CST
Online eBay Store Open 24/7/365!

Contact Us

Live US Based Service & Support. Here for You- Before & After Your Purchases.

One Great Company.
Two Convenient Locations.


Pensacola Hours:
M-F 8am-5pm CST

Physical & Mailing Address:
6401 North Palafox St.
Pensacola, Florida 32503

Local Phone:


Milton Hours:
M-F 8am-5pm CST

Physical & Mailing Address:
5505 Industrial Blvd.
Milton, Florida 32584

Local Phone: 
1-850-472-3120, then press 3

Contact Us and Locations

Send Us An Email

Meet the Team

Butlers Auto Recycling 2021 Pensacola Small Business of the Year

Frequently Asked Questions

How long have you been in business?

Butler Auto Recycling has been in business proudly since 1977. 

What is your primary product or service?

We offer cash and carry new and used automotive parts, engines, transmissions, tires, used batteries, reconditioned batteries, used custom aftermarket rims, aftermarket stereos, speakers, and other vehicle accessories.

How did you first become interested in your line of business? What is your background?

The opportunity came to purchase a building adjacent to our parts store and the storage was available to display used tires in a customer-friendly environment. Our philosophy is that anyone can sell used tires, but it takes that certain company to do it right. We may fall short sometimes, but we learn and become better than before.

How do you differentiate yourself from other businesses in your category and area?

We inventory all of our used and new tires in a computer system which provides real-time inventory to our customers. Our prices include a 90 day warranty. We try to take the guessing game out of what the true price is.

How many locations do you have and do you have plans to expand?

We currently have two (2) stores in Pensacola and Milton, but have plans to expand in the future to help better serve the region.

What type of payments do you accept?

We accept cash, check, Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover

On all parts you buy from Butler's, ask about our

Extended & Lifetime Warranties Available!

Quality Used Vehicles for Sale

Buy Used.
Save Big.

Simple modal box
Part Inquiry Form